respiratory sinus arrhythmia

2020 Meta-Analysis: Slow Breathing Improves A Variety of Behavioral and Physiological Outcomes

Key Points

  • Across 58 studies and 2,485 patients, heart rate variability biofeedback (HRVB) and slow breathing improve a wide range of behavioral and physiological outcomes.

  • These methods provide a simple, safe, and effective complementary therapy that could be useful in a wide variety of settings.

  • Slow breathing (without biofeedback) is likely to be enough, requiring little more than a cellphone application to get started.

The Breathing Diabetic Summary

A hallmark of slow breathing is that it increases heart rate variability (HRV). It does this by increasing respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA), which synchronizes your heart rate with your breathing. When they match, your heart rate increases while you inhale and it decreases while you exhale.

Thus, RSA enhances the “peaks and troughs” of heart rate with each breath, which increases HRV. Because HRV is a robust indicator of overall health and wellness, this is one way in which slow breathing is so powerful. So much so, in fact, that HRV biofeedback (or HRVB) has become extremely popular to help with a variety of problems. 

With HRVB, a person’s “perfect” breathing rate is determined—that is, one that maximizes HRV. And because increases in RSA and HRV are driven by increases in the calming parasympathetic branch of the nervous system, this can reduce negative stress and increase overall resiliency. This has wide-reaching positive benefits.

We’ve covered many of them before. But here are some of the general benefits:

  • Reduced blood pressure.

  • Reduced stress and anxiety.

  • Improved emotional control.

  • Enhanced cognitive function.

  • Better cardio-autonomic function.

  • Improved gas exchange in the lungs.

In this meta-analysis, the authors performed an extensive literature review to examine these benefits of HRVB from a broader statistical perspective. They included papers spanning a wide range of settings, measuring a wide range of outcomes.

Note that, although HRVB sounds fancy (and it can be), many of the benefits are achieved by simply breathing at a rate of about 5-6 breaths per minute.

Therefore, this meta-analysis also included studies that used 6 breaths per minute because:

it is possible that simply doing paced breathing at about six breaths per minute would have the same salutary effects as breathing more exactly at resonance frequency. […] This can easily be taught by following a computer-generated pacing signal or a clock.

From a practical perspective, this might be the most important aspect of this meta-analysis.

After starting with more than 1,500 papers, they ended up with 58 studies having a total of 2,485 patients.

Their statistical analysis of all these studies revealed that HRVB and slow breathing both significantly improve many aspects of health and wellness.

The greatest benefits were for:

  • Athletic performance

  • Artistic performance

  • Depression

  • Gastrointestinal problems

  • Anxiety and anger

  • Respiratory disorders

  • Systolic blood pressure

  • Pain

Smaller, but still meaningful, benefits were found for:

  • Self-reported stress

  • Quality of life

  • Diastolic blood pressure

  • PTSD

  • General energy

  • Sleep

Interestingly, I would have expected several items on the second list to be on the first. But that’s why meta-analyses like this are so important : ) Also, note that measures like “self-reported stress” are harder to quantify. The authors even mention that these results might be the result of how the questionnaires were given.

In any case, the overall results of this meta-analysis are quite exceptional: HRVB and slow breathing both have wide-ranging benefits for overall health and wellness.

These two sentences from the paper sum it up better than I ever could:

These results suggest that HRVB might be a useful addition to the skill sets of clinicians working in a variety of settings, including mental health, behavioral medicine, sports psychology, and education. The method is easy to learn and can easily be used along with other forms of intervention, with rare side effects.

Abstract

We performed a systematic and meta analytic review of heart rate variability biofeedback (HRVB) for various symptoms and human functioning. We analyzed all problems addressed by HRVB and all outcome measures in all studies, whether or not relevant to the studied population, among randomly controlled studies. Targets included various biological and psychological problems and issues with athletic, cognitive, and artistic performance. Our initial review yielded 1868 papers, from which 58 met inclusion criteria. A significant small to moderate effect size was found favoring HRVB, which does not differ from that of other effective treatments. With a small number of studies for each, HRVB has the largest effect sizes for anxiety, depression, anger and athletic/artistic performance and the smallest effect sizes on PTSD, sleep and quality of life. We found no significant differences for number of treatment sessions or weeks between pretest and post-test, whether the outcome measure was targeted to the population, or year of publication. Effect sizes are larger in comparison to inactive than active control conditions although significant for both. HRVB improves symptoms and functioning in many areas, both in the normal and pathological ranges. It appears useful as a complementary treatment. Further research is needed to confirm its efficacy for particular applications.

 

 

Journal Reference:

Lehrer, P., Kaur, K., Sharma, A., Shah, K., Huseby, R., Bhavsar, J., & Zhang, Y. (2020). Heart Rate Variability Biofeedback Improves Emotional and Physical Health and Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis. Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback, 45(3), 109–129. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10484-020-09466-z

 

How Breathing Regulates the Cardiovascular System and Improves Chemosensitivity

Bernardi_et_al-2001_modulatory_WTG.png
 

Key Points

  • Breathing modulates the cardiovascular system through respiratory sinus arrhythmia

  • Slow breathing reduces chemosensitivity to high carbon dioxide and low oxygen

  • Controlled breathing could be a beneficial intervention in different pathological states

The Breathing Diabetic Summary

How does breathing affect us physiologically?  Well, the answer to that is complex.  Breathing is felt by various receptors throughout the body, affecting cardiovascular and autonomic variability on many levels. This review study examined these different modulatory effects of breathing through a comprehensive analysis of the peer-reviewed literature.

 

Breathing and the Cardiovascular System

The cardiovascular system is sensitive to external stimuli. Just picture something scary (like giving a presentation), and your heart rate will likely increase. Consequently, your breathing will also change to match your metabolic needs.

But this is a two-way street. Controlled, rather than reactive, breathing also has profound impacts on the cardiovascular system. This can be temporary, for example, breathing rapidly for one minute, or permanent, for example, developing the behavior/habit of chronic over-breathing.

Knowing that breathing has "direct access" to the cardiovascular system, let's look at how this occurs and how controlled breathing might be beneficial in different pathological states.

 

Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia

One way in which breathing permeates the cardiovascular system is through respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA). RSA is a measurement of how breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure all interact. In simple terms, RSA refers to the increase in heart rate as you inhale and decrease in your heart rate as you exhale. RSA is thought to be an index of vagal activity and direct measurement of heart rate variability.  

When we breathe so that the length of our inhale matches seamlessly with our heart rate increase and our exhale with our heart rate decrease, we maximize RSA. Typically, this occurs when breathing at around 6 breaths per minute. This coherence among respiration and heart rate leads to the maximization of heart rate variability, improving cardiovascular efficiency.

 

Breathing and Chemoreflexes

Slow breathing can reduce breathlessness and improve exercise performance in patients with chronic heart failure. These results suggest that slow breathing could be modifying the chemoreflexes, allowing one to tolerate higher concentrations of carbon dioxide and lower concentrations of oxygen.

To test this hypothesis, a study was conducted with yoga trainees and non-yoga trained participants. Both groups performed different breathing protocols to test their response to high carbon dioxide (hypercapnia) and low oxygen (hypoxia). Although none of these participants had heart problems, the goal was to see if slow breathing could reduce chemoreflexes in the controls to the levels seen in yoga practitioners.

As we might expect, the chemoreflexes of the yoga practitioners at baseline were much lower than the non-trained participants.  This means their breathing did not increase as much when exposed to hypercapnia or hypoxia. Interestingly, the chemoreflexes of the controls decreased to levels similar to the yogis when breathing at 6 breaths per minute.  Therefore, the simple act of slow breathing reduced chemosensitivity to carbon dioxide and hypoxia, regardless of previous training.

These results indicate that breathing could represent another way to better coordinate the breathing muscles, improve chemoreflexes, and improve exercise performance in patients with cardiovascular problems. Slow breathing could, therefore, be a practical alternative when other rehabilitation programs are not available.

 

Breathing Modulates Cardiovascular and Autonomic Control

To summarize, breathing is a potent modulator of cardiovascular and autonomic systems.  Deliberate practice of different breathing patterns (for example, slow breathing) could be beneficial for increasing heart rate variability, improving breathing efficiency, improving chemosensitivity, and enhancing cardio-autonomic control.

 

Abstract

Respiration is a powerful modulator of heart rate variability, and of baro- and chemoreflex sensitivity. Abnormal respiratory modulation of heart rate is often an early sign of autonomic dysfunction in a number of diseases. In addition, increase in venous return due to respiration may help in maintaining blood pressure during standing in critical situations. This review examines the possibility that manipulation of breathing pattern may provide beneficial effects in terms not only of ventilatory efficiency, but also of cardiovascular and respiratory control in physiologic and pathologic conditions, such as chronic heart failure. This opens a new area of future research in the better management of patients with cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction.

 

Journal Reference:

L Bernardi, C Porta, A Gabutti, L Spicuzza, P Sleight.  Modulatory Effects of Respiration.  Auton Neurosci. 2001;90(1-2):47-56. doi: 10.1016/S1566-0702(01)00267-3.